The differences between Apple App Clips and Android Instant Apps

Use an electric scooter without installing an app first? You can, with App Clips and Instant Apps. App Clips is a new extension Apple launched in June. With an App Clip, you only get the features you need at that moment. You might think App Clips is an entirely new idea, but that is not quite true. Google had already released Instant Apps in 2017. It is almost the same, yet there are a few crucial differences. Read all about App Clips and Instant Apps in this blog! Want to go straight to some examples of how these apps are used in practice? Click here.

What are App Clips?

App Clips are small extensions of regular apps: one function offered separately, so it can be used immediately without installing anything. Apple enforces this by capping an App Clip at 10MB. Because they are so small, they work straight away without installing the app first. So you can immediately use the functions you need at that moment. Everything is quick and simple, because you can sign in right away with Sign in with Apple and pay with Apple Pay.

It is important to know that an App Clip's functions are limited. If you only need something at a specific moment, you use just that App Clip. If you later want all the features, you can easily download the app. Watch the App Clips release video below.

What are Instant Apps?

App Clips are not new or groundbreaking. Three years earlier, in 2017, Android launched Instant Apps. These let users open an Instant App with, for example, a QR code. Because the mobile app is limited to 15MB, you can use it directly without downloading the full app first. For businesses that use apps, this is an ideal way to introduce people to your app, so you can make more sales or get more downloads straight away. That was Android's idea, after all. However, it has not been used much yet. Perhaps Apple's App Clips will change that?

You may notice that App Clips and Instant Apps are quite similar. Apple has probably taken a lot of inspiration from how Instant Apps work. Still, there are a few differences that are crucial for success. We will come back to those later.‍

How do Instant Apps work?

Besides being almost the same as Instant Apps, App Clips also work the same way. When you scan a QR code, for example, you get a pop-up with the Instant App, which you can use immediately. This works the same for Instant Apps as for App Clips. At a parking meter, for example, you scan the QR code and can download and use the Instant App straight away.

How do App Clips work?

You know the situation: you park your car and need to pay. To pay at the parking meter you have to remember your licence plate and buy a ticket. Or you download an app to pay for your parking. Downloading an app is easier, but it is still annoying to download a new app for every occasion.

That is what App Clips were created for. You can scan the App Clip code with your iPhone using either the camera or NFC (near-field communication, the contactless chip also used for payments). You take out your phone, scan the code and pay straight away with Apple Pay. Or you use Safari to find, for example, an electric bike. Through the website you can open an App Clip directly and rent the bike. Other options are Apple Maps, QR codes, NFC tags or chat. The image below shows how this works in practice.

Best of both worlds

An App Clip has the advantages of a Progressive Web App (PWA) and of a native app. Best of both worlds! The app also works offline and is very fast. Thanks to NFC tags, built in as standard from the iPhone 7 onwards, you can use the app on your phone directly without opening an app first. You do of course need to unlock your screen to use it.  See how App Clips were used in the G-Star store in Utrecht:

‍What are the benefits?

The benefits of App Clips and Instant Apps are the same. Both are optimised for speed. At a certain moment, a user needs part of the app. With an App Clip or Instant App, the user can use the app immediately. That brings a lot of benefits for both the user and the app owner.

‍Some benefits for the user:

  • Works quickly and easily
  • Can use the app immediately
  • Even if you have no storage space left

‍

Some benefits for the app owner:

  • You send the user straight to the right page
  • More downloads, because the barrier to use is low
  • You engage the user earlier in the customer journey
  • App Clips and Instant Apps work well together with the app

But how much difference does it really make? As an app owner, you want to avoid as much friction as possible. If the regular process is too much work for the user at that moment, they will choose not to use your app. The app download flow has eight steps. The App Clip flow has three, and those steps are also much faster. It may seem a bit exaggerated, but for the user every bit of friction is too much. If you do not use App Clips or Instant Apps in future, you could miss out on a lot of downloads or orders.

Some examples

Here are some examples of how App Clips or Instant Apps are used well. We have already mentioned parking and ordering clothes. But these apps come in handy much more often. Read the practical examples below.

App Clip example 1

Imagine you are having lunch on a terrace with a friend. On the table is a sign with an NFC tag. Do you order from the waiter, or quickly hold your phone against the sign to order your coffee straight away? In 2020, reaching for your phone is becoming more and more common. You are planning a weekend away with your friend.

App Clip example 2

During the weekend away you want to rent a bike. At the bike rack, it turns out you need an app. Do you download the full app, or use an Instant App or App Clip just once? For many people, the choice is easy. Another advantage is that the app stays on the phone for a few weeks and is then removed automatically. So the extension can be used all weekend.

What are the differences?

Now that we have covered almost everything, we come to the question: what is the difference? As we now know, the difference is minimal. The concept of a small app with limited functions is the same for both.

- Instant Apps give you slightly more room, because the maximum size is 15MB instead of 10MB. That does not sound like much, but in percentage terms an Instant App can be 50% larger than an App Clip.
The problem with Instant Apps is that using them still involves some friction. First, Instant Apps has to be switched on in the settings.

- Apple also has a much stronger foundation. Because (almost) every Apple user already uses NFC tags, quick sign-in and Apple Pay, which fit App Clips well, the launch has a better chance of success.

- App Clips also have more ways to connect. With App Clips you can open the apps through App Banners, NFC tags, QR codes, App Clip Codes, Apple Maps and the Apple App Store. Instant Apps has QR codes, App Banners, the Play Store (under 'Try now') or a direct URL.

What are the limits?

The limits of Instant Apps show that there is still too much friction in using them. In some cases it is almost faster to order through the online store than to use the Instant App. For the app developer, the 10 or 15MB limit is also a constraint. So you need to look very carefully at which functions are essential at that moment. The functions should focus on a direct action the user can take. And the user should be satisfied enough to immediately consider downloading the app.

Is this the future?

As a full-service app developer, we see a lot of potential in App Clips and Instant Apps. We also have the knowledge in house to develop these extensions. It is important to know that an extension can only be developed if a complete app exists. For each app, several extensions can be developed for different occasions. It has a lot of potential for app owners and many benefits for users. However, only time will tell. We are positive about it, in any case.

‍

Interested in App Clips or Instant Apps? Get in touch with no obligation, and we will be happy to think along with you.

Job Burg

October 23, 2020

Kom meer te weten

Veelgestelde vragen

When should you choose App Clips or Instant Apps for your concept?

How do you define the scope of such a mini-experience?

What additional technical requirements are involved?

How does this affect App Store review and release processes?

How do you maintain App Clips or Instant Apps over the long term?

Gerelateerde blogs